I think people on here operate on a very weird definition of “conventionally attractive” where anything humanoid is already too normal for them. When society at large is like “if you’re not skinny and white and able bodied and cisgender you’re basically unfuckable”
People on here fetishized Baldywick Clamberspatch, if that can be seen as the baseline for “conventionally attractive” then it’s easy to understand why this site wants to fuck Wheatley