Whatever Homestuck’s flaws, you’ve got to admit that taking the archetypal scheming idiot whose wildly inadvisable plans keep working out for them due to plot-armour levels of impossible luck and going “and also, the ability to do that is literally their super power, so you’re not allowed to call it a plot hole” was a masterstroke of pissing people off.
The fact that this could refer to any number of the following characters really sells it:
Vriska, the obvious one, who’s power is literally to steal people’s luck.
Gamzee, because of weird plot bullshit.
Caliborn/Lord English, who jury-rigged causality itself to cause this.
Rose, via Seer of Light bullshit
Terezi, via Seer of Mind bullshit
And there’s probably more examples tbh