People acting like slavery was good at literally any point in history kinda drive me crazy. There’s been many different types of slavery and indentured servitude all throughout human history all with a lot of difference and nuance to all of them and all of them have been bad. Like it’s fundamentally wrong to take a person’s personal ownership of their own body and life away from them and/or to make them work for no compensation against their will.
Slavery has been a bit different in every society that has practiced it and it is always a different kind of bad with that core immorality of stealing a person’s personal autonomy from them at the center of it. People throughout history have always preferred owning themselves to being owned by others. There’s no ethical way to own another human being.
Like people talk about slavery in ancient times like more modern examples of slavery should’ve been more like that. No, they shouldn’t have. Because they shouldn’t have been practicing slavery at all. Perhaps a third of the Roman Empire’s population was enslaved. It was incredibly normalized. Did that make it right? No. That was a third of the population that could legally be killed or sold or raped by their enslavers at any time for no reason. That had no ownership of themselves or their labor.
And to be clear, slavery still exists and it’s still bad. The excuse now is just that it’s only being done to prisoners. Like all the forms of slavery before it, this justification does not make it right. People being punished for their crimes, whether you think prison time is a justifiable punishment or not, are still people. They need to be given control over what work they apply to do and be paid for their work. This is basic stuff and yet. Forced unpaid labor is still happening. It’s all bad. It’s all nuanced and and complicated and different and changes with culture and time and it’s bad.
Like as someone who loves studying history I hate watching other people who study history try to justify these things. Face your actual history. There’s a lot of bad in it. We can’t change the past but we sure as hell can stop ignoring it.