I hope this doesn't come off as disrespectful, because I'm genuinely curious, but like...is alchemy "real"? Because the way you speak about it is how I wish I could, myself, appreciate it and you're the closest I've ever found to a real world wizard which excites me a great deal. I totally respect if for you it's actually just an interesting academic study without intention, I'm just curious for how you view it in that lens.
No that’s a good question!
Short answer: Yes, as in alchemists were real people who could actually do cool shit sometimes, but they weren’t actually transmuting lead into gold, you need a particle accelerator for that.
In the 4th century, you weren’t a scientist, that word hadn’t been invented yet. You were a Natural Philosopher. You studied everything from the stars, to mathematics, to medicine, to the nature of herbs and stones.
In the medieval era, you weren’t an astronomer, you were an astrologer. Telling people’s horoscopes involved a lot of astronomical math. There wasn’t really a difference between astronomy and astrology.
In the renaissance era, you weren’t a chemist. The term chemist didn’t exist yet. You were an alchemist. You tried to make gold sometimes, but you also manufactured dyes, glass vessels, cosmetics, paints, and medicines. You were kind of a whitesmith, and a glass-blower, and a doctor, and sometimes just a con-man.
Alchemy and chemistry have a relationship similar to Astrology and Astronomy. But, don’t think of alchemy as just “Chemistry with magic.” Alchemy is the father of modern chemistry. It is the cocoon that chemistry sprouted out of.
The thing is, alchemy is more “real” than astrology is. You know what a common use of astrology was in the medieval era? Diagnosing diseases. You’d check someone’s horoscope to determine what medicine to give them. This didn’t work. A medieval astrology textbook isn’t going to be useful for diagnosing why your stomach hurts.
But!
Medieval alchemy texts are actually useful sometimes. If you want to dye some copper so it looked more like gold, there are alchemy texts that can tell you how to do that. If you want to distill the mercury out of some cinnabar, alchemists could do that. They didn’t really know how or why that worked, but they could do it! If you want a potion that could make you immortal, the alchemists could make a philter of mercury and lead that would definitely 100% kill you and it would hurt the whole time you were dying. You can’t win em all.
Im writing about the history of alchemy on my patreon if you wanna support me!